Papineau trial winding down, closing arguments this afternoon
Closing arguments are due shortly in the Iroquois County trial of a Watseka man facing charges for a traffic crash that left another man dead and injured the victim’s grandson.
20-year-old Dakota Papineau is standing trial for the July 2014 crash that killed David Senesac. Senesac’s six-year-old grandson, Landon Shaw, also suffered serious injury.
The accident happened in rural Crescent City at the intersection of 1600E and 1900N.
This afternoon, Circuit Judge James Kinzer denied a direct verdict of acquittal.
The judge earlier today also denied a defense motion for a mistrial. Defense attorney Tony Brasel balked about a statement Iroquois County Sheriff deputy Pat McNally made to the jury that his questioning of the defendant stopped when he learned Dakota Papineau had contacted an attorney.
Brasel argued that statement had prejudiced the jury, assuming guilt.
After that discussion outside the court and case reviews, Kinzer denied the request, instead instructing the jury to disregard.
Brasel also asked for a direct verdict....saying agreed on stipulations that no alcohol or drugs were involved, so the state’s charges of aggravated reckless driving have not merit. He also said running a stop sign doesn’t constitute reckless behavior.
State’s Atty Devine countered saying, deputy McNally’s report indicated there was no ski marks showing attempt to stop and witnesses saying they told Papineau to stop as he approached the intersection.
The judge ruled there was enuf evidence to present the case to the jury.